During this Holy Week, let us contemplate the Passion – the price Jesus paid to redeem us.
And as we exit from this week into the glory of Our Lord’s Resurrection, – first and foremost, let us truly live what we have been so blessed to receive; – then let us make a firm resolution to tell others about this treasure that we have…let us be courageous in sharing what God has done for us, and given us….
This Christian Duty (and IT IS a duty), to share the Gospel with those who haven’t received it is very serious indeed! It can be a sin of omission…if we don’t do it…if we remain silent about our Faith in front of others…especially if others ridicule it.
Jesus Christ: (Son of God and Redeemer of mankind)
“Whoever acknowledges me before men, I will also acknowledge him before my Father in heaven. But whoever disowns me before men, I will disown him before my Father in heaven.” [--- Matt 10:32]
At the beginning of Mass we often pray the “I confess” (the confiteor) which includes this line…
Divine Catholic Liturgy:
“…what I have done and what I have failed to do…” [--- referring to sins of omission]
On this very topic, I was recently sent these news articles (here & here) reporting that the brother of Terri Schiavo (the woman who was murdered/euthanised last year in the US), had denounced his local bishop with a public letter for remaining silent and inactive in the fight to save Terri’s life. The letter strongly condemns the bishop’s lack of action and silence: letter here, and points out his alleged hypocrisy in later teaching about aiding the poor. Read the letter.
This brings up the question/notion of what the duties/obligations of a bishop are with regard to matters that concern him on Faith and Morals, not just inside the Church, but also in society.
Let’s have a look at what the Popes says about this duty of bishops to preach the truth to the world.
Pope Benedict XVI:
“As successors of the apostles you are ‘doctors of the faith,’ authentic doctors who with the same authority of Christ, above all proclaim to the people the faith we must live and believe…” [--- Allocution teaching a group of new prelates, 19 September 2005]
‘Doctor’, from the Latin means ‘Teacher’. Ideally, they should act and teach like true doctors…however in these times….sadly it’s often not the case…with even bishops seriously contradicting the Faith.
Pope Pius XII:
“Catholic theologians and philosophers, whose grave duty it is to defend natural and supernatural truth, and instill it in the hearts of men, cannot afford to ignore or neglect…erroneous opinions.” [--- Humani Generis, Encyclical concerning threats to Catholic Doctrine, 2 August 1950]
Silence on important matters can sometimes mean culpability and complicitness with a crime/sin. Consider those death camps in Nazi Germany and how nearby villagers didn’t want to know what was going on – they preferred to be silent or be willfully ignorant. Or those who didn’t speak up and codemn Nazism when they should have…
Pope Benedict XIV:
“Two chief obligations, have been imposed by the Council of Trent on those who have the care of souls [especially bishops]: first, that of preaching the things of God…and second, that of teaching the rudiments of faith and of the divine law to [those] who need such instruction.” [--- Etsi minime, Encyclical, 7 February, 1742]
So it seems, for a bishop that there is an obligation to the world to (1) proclaim the truth, which means that there is an implicit obligation (2) to refute error, in the process of proclaiming this truth - with regard to Faith and Morals.
Pope Pius X:
![]()
“It is well to emphasize and insist that for a priest [or bishop] there is no duty more grave or obligation more binding than this [to teach the truth].” [--- Acerbo Nimis, Encyclical On Teaching Christian Doctine, 15 April 1905]
Euthanasia touches directly on morals, and in this case it was directly affecting a Catholic family under this bishop’s pastoral care; and was hotly debated in the media all over the world. It was setting a precedent. It needed clear teaching from the local ordinary. Allegedly this bishop refused to help the Schiavo family – a family in his diocese.
Further, St Thomas Aquinas adds that there are 2 obligations for bishops when refuting error:
St Thomas Aquinas:
“Superiors have a double responsibility in this regard, first of all to silence those who teach false doctrine, and secondly to prevent the Faithful from listening to those teaching such doctrine”
How would a bishop silence such teaching of a baptized person? or prevent the baptized listening to such errors? – through fraternal correction of the teacher, by threat of excommunication, by warning his Faithful about the errors, telling them not to go to hear such a teacher, and preventing the use of Catholic premises, including Churches…etc…for the propagation of such error.
How would he silence or refute the errors of non-Catholics in the world on serious matters? By making clear public statements about the Truth and refuting the errors with solid argumentation; and condemning erroneous (or sinful) actions; using all the political power necessary which is available to him – to try and stop it. The Vatican and the Pope often does this.
What does the Catechism say about this:
Catechism of 1992:
“…we have a responsibility for the sins of others when we co-operate with them…by…approving of them…or by…not hindering them when we have an obligation to do so.” [--- CCC 1868]
Lack of teaching against a particular error or sinful action could well be considered “…not hindering them when we have an obligation to do so…”. These days when a bishop or christians speak out against objectively proven heresies, errors, or sins, many christian people, including Catholics, often rally to the defence of the person, or priest, or bishop, who supports the error – as if it is charitable to do so…We should never defend another’s sin – it is one of the ways we participate and become responsible for that sin.
What else do the Popes say…?
Pope Pius X:
“We must now consider upon whom rests the obligation to dissipate this most pernicious ignorance and to impart in its stead the knowledge that is wholly indispensable.
There can be no doubt…that this most important duty rests upon all who are pastors of souls [bishops].”
“On them, by command of Christ, rest the obligations of knowing and of feeding the flocks committed to their care; and to feed implies, first of all, to teach.”
“These are…the pastors and teachers appointed by Christ in order that the faithful might not be as “children, tossed to and fro and carried about by every wind of doctrine devised by the wickedness of men,” but that practicing “the truth in love,” they may, “grow up in all things in him who is the head, Christ.”
“For this reason the Council of Trent, treating of the duties of pastors of souls [above all bishops], decreed that their first and most important work is the instruction of the faithful…”
“The Council provided…by adding that the pastors…must explain the truths of religion…and inculcate obedience to God…”
“The teaching of the Catechism…when rightly done…never fails to profit those who listen to it.” [--- Acerbo Nimis, Encyclical On Teaching Christian Doctine, 15 April 1905]
Teaching is the first duty of the bishop, because without it nobody would be in Church to receive the Sacraments, or instruction. Baptism would not be requested or desired if one hadn’t had Christ preached to them yet, in one way or another.
Pope Pius XI:
“…the Church…can in no way renounce the duty that God has entrusted to her to interpose her authority…in all things that are connected with the moral law.”
“The deposit of truth that God committed to Us, and the grave duty of disseminating and interpreting the whole moral law, and of urging it [teaching it], in season and out of season, bring subject to Our supreme jurisdiction, not only social order, but economic activities themselves.” [--- Quadragesimo Anno, Encyclical on Reconstruction of the Social Order, 15 May 1931]
I think that Terri’s brother has a point….what do you guys think?
On a positive note, here is a briliant example of the Italian bishops teaching moral truth to the world by condemning the proposed civil unions bill and warning Catholic politicians that they have an obligation to vote against it before God: here & here.
CWNews:
Archbishop Angelo Bagnasco said that if the government offers civil-union status to homosexual couples, it will be impossible to draw the line against other relationships. “Why say No to incest?” he asked, adding that “…there would be no clear reason to refuse recognition for pedophiles, too.”
“When one loses the correct conception of the human person, there are no criteria for evaluating good and bad. When the dominant criterion is public opinion, or the voting majority, it is then very difficult to say ‘No’” - the archbishop said. [--- article here]
Cardinal O’Connor of England has also taught the truth strongly about this.
Also the Mexican bishops have strongly taught for life, and condemned the culture of death propagated by the “Herods and Pilates” of our times.
————————————————
Considering this duty to teach truth and refute error for every Christian in their own little circumstances (not just Bishops), I would like to warn against a most dangerous deception that seems to be returning and growing…
Oprah Winfrey is promoting a dangerous New Age deception called “The Secret”. It is a rehash of some old hereises and new age stuff, but it has fast gained world wide acceptance among many people struggling to find happiness in this life. See it here on myspace, and the follow up show here. Have a look and make sure you undertstand what it is and how it is wrong – (we can discuss that in this post). Who knows, somebody may bring it up at work or even in your family.
Peace all – this is Agnes Day’s last post. Hope you’ve enjoyed the ride…










- Foetus at 22 weeks











Recent Comments